The good, bad and the ugly about carbon sequestration
June 28th, 2010 - 2:10 pm ICT by ANILondon, June 28 (ANI): Carbon sequestration is fast gaining popularity as a way to counter global warming. However, its effectiveness and consequences are not yet fully understood. Now, a Niels Bohr Institute researcher is providing an insight into these issues.
Large scale use of carbon sequestration could help to avoid extreme global warming that would otherwise occur in the near future unless fossil fuel emissions are reduced significantly. But it is not clear how effective different types of sequestration are in the long run, owing to leakage of stored CO2 back out to the atmosphere. Nor is it clear what would be the long-term consequences of such leakage for the Earth’s environment.
Gary Shaffer, professor at the Niels Bohr Institute, and leader of the Danish Center for Earth System Science, made long model projections for a number of sequestration/leakage scenarios. His results show that leakage of the stored CO2 may bring about large atmosphere warming, large sea level rise and oxygen depletion, acidification and elevated CO2 concentrations in the ocean.
Storage of CO2 in the deep ocean is a poor choice since this creates grave problems for deep sea life and since CO2 stored this way returns to the atmosphere relatively quickly, bringing back the global warming.
Geological storage may be more effective in delaying the return of the warming and associated consequences but only if a CO2 leakage of 1 % or less per thousand years can be obtained.
Alternatively, one could actively counter leakage from the ocean or geological reservoirs by re-sequestering CO2 to stabilize climate at some desired level. But it would be hard to gauge the global leakage rate to be matched by re-sequestration. Furthermore, re-sequestration would have to be carried out over many thousands of years, a burden for future society in line with that of long term management of nuclear waste.
Shaffer said: “CO2 sequestration has many potential advantages over other forms of climate geoengineering. It makes good sense to modify the Earth’s radiation balance by putting carbon back in where it came from.
Atmospheric CO2 is long-lived and evenly-distributed globally making it possible to manage it in a long-term, controlled way with less chance for unpleasant climate surprises. However, one should not underestimate potential short and long-term problems with leakage from underground reservoirs. Carbon in light form will seek its way out of the ground or seabed. The present situation in the Gulf of Mexico is a poignant reminder of that.”
Shaffer believes that “the dangers of carbon sequestration are real and the development of this technique should not be used as an argument for continued high fossil fuel emissions. On the contrary, we should greatly limit CO2 emissions in our time to reduce the need for massive carbon sequestration and thus reduce unwanted consequences and burdens over many future generations from the leakage of sequestered CO2.”
The research appears in the journal Nature Geoscience. (ANI)
- Scrubbing CO2 from air could be a long-term commitment - Jul 02, 2010
- Thawing arctic soil may release greenhouse gases - Nov 07, 2011
- Experts study black carbon, tropospheric ozone's role in climate change - Feb 21, 2011
- Genetically altered trees could reduce global warming - Oct 02, 2010
- Underground CO2 leakage could contaminate drinking water - Nov 12, 2010
- New CO2 model to ensure that Earth doesn't heat up beyond two degrees - Aug 03, 2010
- Climate change mitigation strategies ignore carbon cycling processes of inland waters - Sep 02, 2009
- Earth's hot past indicates much hotter future - Jan 16, 2011
- Large CO2 release accelerates ice age melting - Aug 27, 2010
- Climate change stifling ocean's carbon uptake - Jul 11, 2011
- Controlling man made emissions may delay start of next ice age - Feb 11, 2009
- Global warming was 'more common 50m yrs ago' - Mar 17, 2011
- NALCO to set up pilot project on managing carbon - Mar 22, 2011
- Ocean warming might hit microbes' carbon storage capacity - Feb 13, 2012
- The Climate Change Terminology (To go with Curtain Raiser) - Nov 27, 2011
Tags: acidification, carbon sequestration, co2 concentrations, danish center, deep ocean, earth system science, fossil fuel emissions, future society, gary shaffer, grave problems, institute researcher, leakage rate, long term management, model projections, niels bohr institute, oxygen depletion, poor choice, sea level rise, sea life, term consequences