Pachauri was told of false glacier claims before Copenhagen
January 30th, 2010 - 1:29 pm ICT by ANILondon, January 30 (ANI): Reports indicate that Rajendra Pachauri, Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) was informed that claims about melting Himalayan glaciers were false before the Copenhagen summit.
According to a report in The Times, Dr Pachauri was told that the IPCC assessment that the glaciers would disappear by 2035 was wrong, but he waited two months to correct it.
The report says that he failed to act despite learning that several leading glaciologists had refuted the claim.
The IPCC’s report underpinned the proposals at Copenhagen for drastic cuts in global emissions.
Dr Pachauri, who played a leading role at the summit, corrected the error last week after coming under media pressure.
He told The Times on January 22 that he had only known about the error for a few days.
“I became aware of this when it was reported in the media about ten days ago. Before that, it was really not made known. Nobody brought it to my attention. There were statements, but we never looked at this 2035 number,” he had said.
Asked whether he had deliberately kept silent about the error to avoid embarrassment at Copenhagen, he had said, “That’s ridiculous. It never came to my attention before the Copenhagen summit. It wasn’t in the public sphere.”
Dr Pachauri had previously dismissed a report by the Indian Government which said that glaciers might not be melting as much as had been feared.
He described the report, which did not mention the 2035 error, as “voodoo science”.
However, a prominent science journalist said that he had asked Dr Pachauri about the 2035 error last November.
Pallava Bagla, who writes for Science journal, said he had asked Dr Pachauri about the error.
He said that Dr Pachauri had replied, “I don’t have anything to add on glaciers.”
Bagla said he had informed Dr Pachauri that Graham Cogley, a professor at Ontario Trent University and a leading glaciologist, had dismissed the 2035 date as being wrong by at least 300 years.
Professor Cogley believed the IPCC had misread the date in a 1996 report that said the glaciers could melt significantly by 2350. (ANI)
- UN climate body admits goof up on Himalayan glaciers - Jan 20, 2010
- India's Pallava Bagla gets US science journalism award - Dec 17, 2010
- Indian scribe wins American Geophysical Union Award - Aug 31, 2010
- Indian wins American science journalism award - Sep 01, 2010
- Pachauri under pressure to resign over Himalayan glacier goof up - Feb 04, 2010
- Pachauri calls Indian govt. report on melting Himalayan glaciers as "voodoo science" - Jan 09, 2010
- 'Warning on melting Himalayan glaciers wildly inaccurate' - Jan 21, 2010
- Science writer Fred Pearce asks Dr. Pachauri to step down as IPCC Chairman - Oct 03, 2010
- Put on notice, India's Pachauri tasked with carrying out IPCC reform - Oct 20, 2010
- IPCC's report on Himalayan glaciers could have more errors, admits Pachauri - Jan 23, 2010
- Pachauri too doubts if glaciers would vanish by 2035 (Lead) - Jan 18, 2010
- Scientists slam IPCC blunder, chief goes mum (Roundup) - Jan 21, 2010
- Himalayan glaciers won't melt by 2035: Jairam Ramesh - Jan 18, 2010
- Rajendra Pachauri must quit, says Britain's ex-minister - Sep 24, 2010
- Pressure mounting for Rajendra Pachauri to resign as IPCC head - Sep 23, 2010
Tags: bagla, cogley, copenhagen, drastic cuts, embarrassment, few days, glaciologist, global emissions, himalayan glaciers, indian government, intergovernmental panel on climate change, intergovernmental panel on climate change ipcc, ipcc assessment, last november, pallava, public sphere, science journal, science journalist, trent university, voodoo science