No evidence to support ’smoke 23 times more toxic in vehicle than in home’ claimApril 13th, 2010 - 3:50 pm ICT by ANI
Washington, April 13 (ANI): The claim that smoking in cars is 23 times more toxic than in other indoor environments does not appear to be based on scientific evidence.
A team of Australian researchers described how a local media report of an unsourced statistic - that ’second-hand smoke was “23 times more toxic in a vehicle than in a home” - led to widespread reporting of the figure in international media and peer-reviewed literature.
However, there appears to be no scientific evidence to support this claim, the researchers said.
“In a subsequent exhaustive search of the relevant literature, we failed to locate any scientific source for this comparison,” write Mr. Ross MacKenzie, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, Australia and coauthor.
“Given that the issue of banning smoking in cars is gaining traction internationally, use of this media-friendly tobacco control ‘fact’ presents potential problems of credibility.”
The 23 times estimate has evolved from being a brief quotation in a US newspaper to entering the academic mainstream in 1998 when a Tobacco Control editorial closely copied the previous quote. Both the newspaper report and the editorial were then cited in an issue of Nicotine and Tobacco Research.
“The biggest danger of inaccurately interpreting research on smoking in cars for the sake of a snappy media sound bite is to lose favour with an overwhelmingly supportive public and to provide ammunition for opponents of tobacco control,” the authors said.
The authors conclude that researchers and organizations should stop using the 23 times more toxic ‘fact’ because of the lack of evidence in scientific literature.
“Instead, advocating of smoking bans in cars should simply state that exposure to second-hand smoke in cars poses a significant health risk and that vulnerable children who cannot remove themselves from this smoky environment must be protected,” the researhcesr said.
The new research has been described in Canadian Medical Association Journal. (ANI)
- Second-hand cigarette smoke associated with raised blood pressure in boys - May 02, 2011
- British doctors want ban on smoking in cars - Nov 16, 2011
- How second-hand smoke may increase vulnerability to nicotine addiction - May 03, 2011
- Tobacco control is most cost-effective way to prevent cancer - Feb 04, 2010
- Tobacco firm underplayed dangers of smoking - Jan 09, 2012
- 'Thirdhand smoke' dangerous to unborn babies' lungs - Apr 20, 2011
- Beware! Passive smoking riskier than you think (May 31 is World No Tobacco Day) - May 30, 2012
- Passive smoking can harm your unborn baby - Mar 10, 2011
- World Environment Day (WED 2010): Smoke-free environment is a right - Jun 05, 2010
- Flat-dwelling kids 'more likely to be exposed to tobacco smoke' - Dec 14, 2010
- Must work towards moving farmers out of tobacco industry: Azad - Oct 19, 2010
- All US workplaces could be smoke-free by 2020 - Apr 22, 2011
- As hookah becomes in, it raises health concerns (Lifestyle Feature) - May 06, 2012
- Study pushes for smoke-free car laws to protect infants - May 02, 2011
- Passive smoking ups risk of still births by 23 percent - Mar 10, 2011
Tags: australian researchers, banning smoking in cars, exhaustive search, health risk, indoor environments, interpreting research, mackenzie school, mr ross, public health university, relevant literature, ross mackenzie, school of public health, second hand smoke, smoking bans, smoky environment, supportive public, tobacco control, tobacco research, university of sydney, university of sydney australia