Lower obesity threshold in British Asians, say Indian experts
July 10th, 2009 - 1:37 pm ICT by ANILondon, July 10 (ANI): Experts have called upon to lower the threshold for being overweight and obese in British Asians.
Indian health chiefs have carried out changes in measuring system to take into account that people of south Asian origin are more likely than whites to develop heart disease and diabetes.
They also insist other countries should follow suit for people of South Asian origin.
The global standards used to assess whether someone is overweight or obese are based on the data derived from Caucasians.
According to these standards, people with body mass index of 25 or more are considered overweight and they are obese if it goes above 30.
However, in India, these standards have been lowered to 23 and 25. They also have lower thresholds for waist circumference measurements.
Dr Anoop Misra, who helped to draw up India’s guidelines, said that the new measures should be applied for people with a South Asian background wherever they live.
“They should be followed for South Asians - Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Nepalis - they are almost similar,” the BBC quoted him as saying.
“So for the time being, until guidelines for other population groups are available, I think this should be applicable for all south Asians - not only in the UK, but in any country of the world,” he added.
Dr. Ponnusammy Saravanan, from the South Asian Health Foundation, said that more research was needed before treatment is brought forward.
“There is no doubt that lifestyle modifications will prevent future diabetes and cardiovascular disease. That is clearly proven,” he said.
“However there’s still very limited evidence of introducing drug treatment and bariatric surgery at a lower threshold for South Asians. We clearly need more studies on those areas before we embark on a wider scale in the NHS,” he added.
Although Professor Stephen Field, president of the Royal College of GPs, supports earlier intervention with drugs and surgery for British Asians, he didn’t agree that Indian approach should be applied in the UK.
“The evidence is there. This is an urgent situation because of the increase in diabetes across the Asian population in the UK. Our patients are at risk. They need to be identified early, and treated aggressively,” he said. (ANI)
- International Diabetes Federation backs surgery in fight against diabetes - Mar 29, 2011
- India's overweight population rises by 70 million (Lead) - Jul 15, 2009
- India's overweight population goes up by 70 million - Jul 15, 2009
- Wider hips protect against diabetes - Jan 24, 2012
- Trial underway to test whether surgery is best option for type 2 diabetes - Feb 11, 2011
- Exercising beneficial for the obese - Feb 21, 2012
- UK surgeons call for changes in weight-loss surgery rules - Jan 23, 2011
- Bariatric surgery bringing hope for diabetics (Nov 14 is World Diabetes Day) - Nov 13, 2011
- Bariatric surgery cuts long-term cardiovascular risk in diabetics - Mar 31, 2011
- Bariatric surgery is better at controlling glucose levels than dieting - Apr 28, 2011
- Scientists exploring obesity's root causes - Sep 24, 2011
- Weight loss improves testosterone levels - Jun 05, 2011
- Bariatric surgery can 'safely' cut health risk in severely obese - Mar 15, 2011
- Body fat predicts the risk of diabetes better than BMI - Jul 16, 2010
- Bariatric ops reduce chances of gestational diabetes - Sep 08, 2010
Tags: anoop, asian background, asian health, body mass index, circumference measurements, diabetes and cardiovascular disease, global standards, health chiefs, health foundation, heart disease and diabetes, indian health, lifestyle modifications, measuring system, misra, population groups, professor stephen, saravanan, south asian origin, south asians, waist circumference