Failure to eradicate polio worldwide is ‘violation of ethical obligation’April 16th, 2010 - 2:44 pm ICT by ANI
Washington, April 16 (ANI): Experts have commented that failure to pursue eradication of polio worldwide, even with the capability and resources provided, is a violation of ethical principles.
According to ethicists, foremost among them is a “duty to rescue” those in distress.
Claudia Emerson, PhD, Program Leader in Ethics, and Peter A. Singer, MD, Director of the Canadian-based McLaughlin-Rotman Centre for Global Health (MRC) at the University Health Network and University of Toronto, present a series of compelling arguments that completing polio eradication is an ethical imperative.
They say the polio eradication agenda in recent years has largely centred on questions of economic and technical feasibility and has come under fire from opponents who strongly support an ‘effective control’ strategy.
However, it is estimated that this alternative to eradication would result in 4 million children contracting polio in the next 20 years.
The authors introduce a moral justification for eradication to the debate, asking: “How can we ethically justify this course of action when the opportunity and means to rescue are available?”
“Examining only economic aspects of eradication overlooks an important moral calculation: the human cost of failing to eradicate,” they said.
“This is the cost of lives not saved, the lives afflicted by polio (including those family members who care for paralysed children), and the impact of those lives on the future of the broader community.
“Obligations to future generations are difficult to define and may be limited, but if preventing harm is a moral duty, there may be a chain of obligation that persists through generations,” they stated.
The authors said that the eradication of smallpox, effectively accomplished in the late 1970s, has resulted in up to 2 million lives saved and 10-15 million smallpox infections prevented annually.
“No one is further threatened by this disease. The eradication of polio would similarly achieve global public good,” they said.
“The Global Polio Eradication Initiative has already made strides in this direction: since its launch in 1988, over 2 billion children have been immunized and a 99 percent reduction in polio has been achieved.
“Arguably, those who enjoy the benefits of public goods ought to be motivated to act in pursuit of such goods, thus the onus is on the global community to continue supporting polio eradication efforts,” they stated.
According to the authors, self-interest adds a strong reason to pursue polio eradication.
Although polio has been absent from the developed world for over 30 years, the threat of re-emergence looms in a world where people and viruses easily cross international borders.
Polio remains endemic in four countries - India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Nigeria - and over the years has been exported to previously polio-free countries in sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere.
“We are on the last kilometre of a marathon; surely it is worth crossing the finish line,” the authors concluded.
The article will be published by the Lancet online April 15 and in the print edition April 17, a month prior to the start of the 63rd session of the World Health Assembly in May in Geneva, at which the Global Polio Eradication Initiative will present its aggressive new strategy aimed at wiping out polio in the next 3 years.
The article also coincides with the 55th anniversary of the 1955 announcement by Jonas Salk of the world’s first polio vaccine. (ANI)
- Polio-free Southeast Asia within reach: WHO - Sep 05, 2012
- Polio funds get a boost in India: Rotary International - Feb 10, 2012
- Indian firm joins Nigeria's polio battle (With Images) - Feb 23, 2012
- Pakistani daily lauds India for no polio cases in 2011 - Jan 14, 2012
- Polio under control but India aims at eradication: Azad - Oct 23, 2011
- Indian Olympic athletes appeal to root out polio - Aug 02, 2012
- 'Ensure regular vaccination to make India polio free' - Feb 23, 2012
- WHO lauds India's year without polio (Lead) - Jan 13, 2012
- India faces polio threat from Pakistan: Minister - Dec 20, 2011
- Bill Gates discusses polio, other health related issues in Pakistan with Zardari - Apr 07, 2011
- Pakistan committed to eradicate polio this year: Gilani - Jan 28, 2012
- Global polio eradication initiative may save $40-50bn - Nov 23, 2010
- 'Low chances of polio coming to India from Pakistan' - May 31, 2012
- India to support global polio eradication: Azad - Feb 26, 2012
- India should be polio free in three years: Rotary International - Mar 30, 2011
Tags: broader community, community obligations, control strategy, erad, eradication of smallpox, ethical imperative, ethical obligation, ethicists, moral duty, moral justification, obligations to future generations, paralysed children, phd program, polio eradication, program leader, rotman, singer md, technical feasibility, university health network, university of toronto