Does equality result in increased status spending?
December 23rd, 2010 - 6:21 pm ICT by ANIWashington, Dec 23 (ANI): A new study has pointed out that while people are happier when goods are more equally distributed, equality makes them to spend more to get ahead of their neighbours.
Researchers Nailya Ordabayeva (Erasmus University, The Netherlands) and Pierre Chandon (INSEAD, France) examined the way equality influences the consumption decisions of people in the bottom tiers of social groups.
They found that increasing equality decreases bottom-tier consumer envy of what other people have and boosts their satisfaction with their possessions.
But increasing equality also raises the possibility of surpassing someone else.
“In other words, equality increases the social gain (the boost in one’s rank in the distribution) provided by spending,” explained the researchers.
They tested their predictions by asking participants to imagine they were at the bottom of the distribution in their social group.
Then they manipulated the distribution so that sometimes it was relatively equal and other times lopsided.
Study participants were asked to decide whether to save money or to spend money on purchases that would improve their status by moving them to a higher tier in the distribution.
In one study, the authors created a hypothetical situation where participants vied for status represented by the amount of flower bushes in their yards.
“We found that people with no flower bushes were happier with what they had when the distribution was equal and the gap with other people’s gardens was not so apparent,” the researchers wrote.
“But the same happy people were more likely to spend money to beautify their garden when the gap was low. Thus, equality decreased envy but increased status spending,” they added.
The pattern repeated when consumers were spending on branded clothing and flat-screen TVs and when they were in a competitive mindset.
However, equality reduced spending when people sought status-neutral products or when they were in a cooperative mindset.
“People do not only compete with the Joneses because they are envious,” the authors wrote.
“Sometimes people compete with the Joneses because it allows them to climb the social distribution in a cost-effective way,” they said.
The study appears the Journal of Consumer Research. (ANI)
- Jealous of someone? You'll end up paying more to be like them - Oct 19, 2010
- Positively jealous people buy iPhones, hateful envious, Blackberries - Oct 20, 2010
- Sexual competition makes women more jealous than men - May 04, 2012
- Fear of being envied makes people act more helpfully toward others - Dec 04, 2010
- How a leader is chosen impacts whether others will follow - Dec 03, 2010
- Teens junking healthy lifestyle kiss happiness away - Mar 04, 2012
- More people turn to god in societies under stress - Aug 09, 2011
- Slogans about saving money actually increase spending: Study - Sep 21, 2010
- Why some people never seem to forget a face - Dec 04, 2011
- Frequent flower buyers seek more variety - Nov 05, 2009
- Fear of malacious envy makes us helpful - Dec 05, 2010
- Happiness lies in earning more than peers! - Mar 20, 2010
- Cuddle chemical oxytocin advances negative emotions - Aug 02, 2011
- Materialistic people ridden with anxiety - Apr 10, 2012
- Can it hurt consumers to tell white lies? - Oct 23, 2011
Tags: branded clothing, bushes, consumption decisions, envy, equality, erasmus university, flat screen tvs, flower, gap, hypothetical situation, insead france, mindset, neighbours, pierre chandon, possessions, satisfaction, social group, social groups, study participants, tiers