Design flaws may have doomed the “Big Bang Machine”
February 24th, 2010 - 2:16 pm ICT by ANI
London, Feb 24 (ANI): A senior scientist who helped to build the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is claiming that the cause of the shutdown of the giant particle accelerator in 2008 was not a freak accident, but a crucial flaw in the machine’s design.
Running more than a year behind schedule and at half its intended energy, the world’s most powerful particle accelerator is slated to begin its first full scientific run this week.
But, according to a report in Nature News, Lucio Rossi, a physicist who oversaw the production of the accelerator’s superconducting magnets, is claiming that the cause of the delay - a major accident in 2008 - could have been avoided.
“Any technical fault is a human fault,” said Rossi.
Rossi said that the catastrophic failure of a splice between two magnets was not a freak accident, but the result of poor design and lack of quality assurance and diagnostics.
On September 19, 2008, just weeks before the LHC was first scheduled to start colliding protons, an electrical short caused massive damage.
A connection between two superconducting cables developed a small amount of resistance, which warmed the connection until the cables - cooled by liquid helium to superconducting temperatures - lost their ability to carry current.
Thousands of amps arced through the machine, blowing a hole in its side and releasing several tonnes of liquid helium.
The expanding helium gas created havoc, spewing soot into the machine’s ultraclean beamline and ripping magnets from their stands.
Repairs took more than a year, and the LHC successfully restarted last November.
An investigation revealed that technicians had not properly soldered the cables together.
“With tens of thousands of such connections, it is perhaps inevitable that some were faulty, but design flaws worsened the problem,” Rossi said.
The silver-tin solder that was used melted at high temperatures and did not flow easily into the cable joints.
Moreover, workers did not adequately check to see if each connection was electrically secure.
Sensors to detect an overheating circuit, which might have helped prevent the accident, were not installed until after it happened.
When the wires were originally joined, the same silver-tin solder was used to connect them to an adjacent copper stabilizer, meant to provide an escape route for current in the event of a failure, according to Rossi.
“That step risked reheating and destroying the original connection,” he said.
Making the second connection to the stabilizer with a different type of solder that had a lower melting point could have avoided the problem.
The project, according to Rossi, will be coping with the consequences for many months to come.
“What we have to do is learn from our mistakes and make it better,” he said. (ANI)
- 'Big Bang Machine' fizzling out because of faulty magnets - Aug 04, 2009
- Large Hadron Collider gets warning system upgrade - Sep 29, 2009
- Repair plan for Atom Smasher being finalized - Oct 30, 2008
- "Big Bang" machine becomes colder than deep space - Oct 17, 2009
- Large Hadron Collider performing well - Mar 09, 2010
- 'Big Bang' machine almost ready to run again - May 04, 2009
- Large Hadron Collider sets new beam intensity record - Apr 23, 2011
- Particle beams successfully injected into "Big Bang Machine" - Oct 27, 2009
- 'Big Bang Machine' experiment successful: CERN - Mar 30, 2010
- LHC to be run for an extra yr to find the Higgs particle - Dec 11, 2010
- Big Bang Machine to re-start in October - Feb 10, 2009
- Large Hadron Collider may start collisions by Christmas - Aug 08, 2009
- "Atom smasher" out of action till at least June 2009 - Oct 18, 2008
- 'Big Bang Machine' restarts after 14 months of repairs - Nov 21, 2009
- Giant particle smasher to restart at half its designed energy - Aug 07, 2009
Tags: bang machine, beamline, cable joints, catastrophic failure, design flaws, freak accident, hadron collider, helium gas, high temperatures, lhc, liquid helium, london feb, lucio rossi, major accident, massive damage, particle accelerator, superconducting magnets, superconducting temperatures, technical fault, ultraclean