Call for ban on lump-detecting Breastlight torch
December 18th, 2009 - 3:47 pm ICT by ANI ( Leave a comment )London, Dec 18 (ANI): A well-known British breast cancer charity has appealed Boots the chemist to refrain from selling the Breastlight, which claims to detect lumps in breasts.
According to Cancer Research, there is “no clear evidence” that the Breastlight torch could discover cancerous lumps, and either led to anxiety in women using it or made them carefree.
The device priced at 85 pounds is marketed as a “health and wellbeing” product and works by shining a light through the tissue, revealing an “internal” view of the breast, thereby, showing any unusual dark shapes, which could be lumps.
Although, trials of the Breastlight at Sunderland City Hospital saw the product identify abnormalities in 12 out of 18 women diagnosed with malignant tumours, Dr Lesley Walker, the director of cancer information at Cancer Research UK, believes women should not depend on the product.
“There is no clear evidence to show this sort of home testing kit could reliably detect breast cancer,” the Scotsman quoted Walker, as saying.
She added: “There’s a danger that use of the device could leave some women with increased levels of anxiety and others with false reassurance.”
The Scottish Breast Cancer Campaign had also voiced similar concerns.
“As breast cancer advocates, we pointed out to Breastlight that, even if a woman found an ‘abnormality’ with the light, she would find it extremely difficult for a GP to refer her on to a breast clinic on the evidence of ’shadows’ produced by a torch. Thus, the product could create needless anxiety,” said the charity.
However, PWB Health, the manufacturer of the Breastlight said it has “never sought” the approval of charities.
“It must be stressed that Breastlight is not a diagnostic tool and should not be used as a substitute for mammogram screening. Some women may choose to use Breastlight as an accessory to their existing breast awareness practices, while others may prefer to rely on familiarity with their bodies when looking for changes to their breasts,” Alex Gourlay, chief executive of the health and beauty division at Boots, said. (ANI)
- Now, a do-it-yourself device for breast cancer detection - Jul 31, 2008
- Women with false-positive mammograms suffer serious anxiety - Jan 14, 2011
- Experts offer 10 tips for breast cancer screening and early detection - Oct 10, 2010
- Future docs may have to pass new breast exam test - Mar 25, 2011
- Annual mammograms beginning at 40 save 71pc more lives: Study - Jan 28, 2011
- New scanner device developed to detect breast cancer in seconds - Oct 29, 2010
- Eight cancer signs identified - Aug 28, 2010
- Women's breast riddled with metal by mistake - Mar 23, 2011
- Increased use of Computer-aided detection in mammography - Oct 02, 2010
- Mammograms less effective in detecting cancer - Sep 24, 2010
- No need to wait until age 50 for breast cancer screening: Study - Oct 01, 2010
- Now, screen breast cancer at home - Oct 28, 2010
- As breast cancer spreads in India, awareness is key (Feature) - Sep 01, 2010
- Soon, simple blood test to detect breast cancer - Apr 06, 2010
- Sheryl Crow opens breast cancer center - 'The Sheryl Crow Imaging Center' - Aug 27, 2010
Tags: abnormality, boots the chemist, breast awareness, breast cancer, breast cancer campaign, breast clinic, cancer charity, cancer information, cancer research uk, cancerous lumps, clear evidence, dark shapes, diagnostic tool, health and wellbeing, levels of anxiety, lumps in breasts, malignant tumours, needless anxiety, reassurance, sunderland city