A new vision of climate change needed to combat skepticismMay 28th, 2010 - 4:45 pm ICT by ANI
Washington, May 28 (ANI): A British is looking into ways new ‘visual strategies’ can communicate climate change messages against a backdrop of increased climate scepticism.
Dr Manzo, from Newcastle University, said: “There have been various efforts to put a face on the climate change issue.
“Communicators need to move away from the traditional images of polar bears or fear-laden imagery to find new, inspirational motifs to engage people with climate change. My research has uncovered a variety of possibilities - such as windmills as icons of renewable energy - as well as alternatives to documentary photography as the dominant form of climate change communication. Artists and cartoonists are among the producers of inspirational alternatives.
“A recent study of American public perception showed that fewer people are convinced of the reality of climate change, and of those that are only 36 percent attribute it to human activity. This shows the variance of levels of climate change knowledge and understanding, which effects how people behave in response. It also highlights the need for strategies to boost the cognitive and behavioural elements of climate change engagement without resorting to methods such as fear appeals that are, at best, a double edged sword.”
In her study Manzo analysed the traditional standard bearing symbols of climate change, especially polar bears, which (like the images of the global poor that sometimes appear in relation to climate change) are traditionally cast as being ‘helpless’ and ’stranded’ victims as their habitat changes around them.
The most famous example of a polar bear gaining iconic status is Knut, the cub from Berlin Zoo whose image was used so successfully for political and commercial campaigns that he became the biggest cash grossing animal of all time.
Manzo said: “Polar bears score highly in the so called identifiable victim stakes. Findings suggest that the image of a lone polar bear, like Knut, wins hands down in the affective stakes provoking feelings of pity and concern as well as charitable giving.”
To find if the time was ripe for those communicating climate change messages to find a new motif, Manzo studied recent charity campaigns, climate change photography and the framing of climate change articles in the press.
Manzo suggests that icons of extreme weather and renewable energy are the standard alternatives to faces of climate change, with images such as windmills providing an inspirational approach to a climate change message which is inherently difficult to visualise.
She said: “Visually pleasing images have indirect value when they allow organisations that use them to raise money for climate action and science. Icons of renewable energy, such as windmills, change the frame of reference from either business as usual or visions of apocalypse to possible strategies of mitigation.”
Manzo added: “All of these alternatives represent efforts to move beyond polar bears as the iconic representation of climate change and the visual sign of the so called ‘age of the melt’.
“The challenge is to use visuals creatively in ways that can address all three aspects of climate change communication, i.e. cognition, affect and behaviour, without enhancing a sense of fatalism and disengagement.”
The study has appeared in Meteorological Applications. (ANI)
- Brain problems killed Knut the polar bear, says Berlin zoo - Mar 23, 2011
- Polar bear Knut to become world's most famous stuffed animal - Mar 24, 2011
- Number of polar bears to fall, courtesy climate change - Nov 25, 2010
- Polar bears 'can be saved from extinction by emission cuts' - Dec 16, 2010
- Knut the polar bear was killed by a stroke - Mar 27, 2011
- ICTs can help Kerala adapt to climate change - Nov 19, 2011
- Polar bear births could plummet due to climate change - Feb 09, 2011
- Asperger's no obstacle for young Kolkata inventor (Feature) - May 14, 2012
- Polar bear's record 9-day continuous swim blamed on global warming - Jan 26, 2011
- Does a stronger Sun actually cool Earth? - Oct 07, 2010
- Knut the polar bear's death could have been avoided: PETA - Mar 20, 2011
- Israel to host Indian art exhibition (With Image) - Mar 01, 2012
- Bihar broke energy promises: Greenpeace India - Mar 03, 2011
- Polar bears at risk as melting ice is making them swim greater distances - Jan 26, 2011
- Heart failure linked with grey matter loss - Feb 05, 2012
Tags: berlin zoo, cartoonists, change communication, change messages, climate change issue, climate change knowledge, commercial campaigns, communication artists, documentary photography, double edged sword, fear appeals, habitat changes, manzo, newcastle university, polar bear, polar bears, public perception, traditional images, visual strategies, windmills