SC chides government over Bhopal’s toxic waste (Lead)May 28th, 2012 - 11:06 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, May 28 (IANS) The Supreme Court Monday chided the central government for not doing anything for disposing toxic waste for 28 years since the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy.
An apex court bench of Justice G.S. Singhvi and Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya said that there was total “apathy” in dealing with the situation “because the victims of Bhopal gas tragedy are poor”.
The apex court is hearing a government plea challenging an order of the Madhya Pradesh High Court directing the secretary of the environment and forests ministry to appear before it.
For 28 years you have not decided and “even the affidavit is vague. There is a lack of seriousness. We will ask the high court to consider since it is dealing with the situation”, the court said.
Referring to protests at Pithampur in Madhya Pradesh where the toxic waste was sought to be disposed, the judges said wherever people had an apprehension about their lives and health, they had a right to protest.
The court asked Additional Solicitor General Gourab Banerji to tell how many meetings a group of ministers (GoM) held on the issue.
“How many meetings did the GoM have because we find that in your affidavit…there is no mention about decisions taken” by it, the court said.
The central government in its affidavit said that the GoM decided to accept the Madhya Pradesh government’s proposal on disposing the Union Carbide’s toxic waste by employing the state-run German Society for International Cooperation (GIZ).
The GoM had asked the state government to find out all the details by June 8 and submit a report, it said.
Banerji told the court that from 2004 there were four proposals for the consideration of the government for incineration of the toxic waste.
A proposal to dispose the waste at a site in Gujarat was disallowed by the Gujarat Pollution Control Board.
He told the court that there was a move to dispose the waste at Pithampur but it too had to be shelved because of objections and apprehension of law and order problem.
The additional solicitor general told the court that the matter would be decided soon and a final call will be taken during the meeting of the GoM June 8.
Appearing for the Madhya Pradesh government, senior counsel Ravi Shankar Prasad told the court that by June 5 “we are expecting a report from GIZ. This court should wait for the report to come”.
Fixing the next hearing July 2, the court said that it was ready to give the Madhya Pradesh government a “chance”.
On the night of Dec 2-3, 1984, tonnes of methyl isocyanate gas leaked from the Union Carbide’s pesticides plant in Bhopal, killing several thousand people. The toxic waste is lying at the plant since then.
- Chidambaram promises modern hospital for gas victims - Jun 05, 2012
- Apex court slams tardy progress in UCC toxic waste disposal - Jul 14, 2012
- SC chides government over Bhopal's toxic waste - May 28, 2012
- Union Carbide's toxic waste to be incinerated - May 02, 2010
- US court absolves Union Carbide in Bhopal gas tragedy (Second Lead) - Jun 29, 2012
- Not enough done for Bhopal tragedy victims: Activist - Jan 12, 2012
- Chouhan wants panel to assess pollution around Union Carbide - Jan 05, 2012
- Bhopal gas probe panel invites information - Aug 18, 2011
- Bhopal Gas Tragedy: High Court directs Dow Chemicals to disclose its business interests - Jul 22, 2010
- Remove Bhopal toxic waste in six months, orders SC - Aug 09, 2012
- GoM on Bhopal begins second day meeting - Jun 19, 2010
- Bhopal panel recommends enhanced Rs.72 crore compensation - Sep 27, 2010
- GoM ends fourth meeting, report before PM tomorrow: Chidambaram - Jun 20, 2010
- Bhopal ministerial panel looking at legal options (Lead) - Jun 19, 2010
- Dumped Carbide waste should be moved out of Pithampur: NGOs - Jul 11, 2010
Tags: 28 years, affidavit, apathy, apex court, apprehension, bhopal gas tragedy, central government, court bench, german society, gujarat, incineration, international cooperation, madhya pradesh government, many meetings, pithampur, pollution control board, seriousness, solicitor general, toxic waste, union carbide