US judge dismisses Harry Potter plagiarism suitJanuary 7th, 2011 - 2:57 pm ICT by ANI
Melbourne, Jan 07 (ANI): A US federal judge has dismissed Harry Potter plagiarism lawsuit.
It was alleged that the wildly-successfully JK Rowling books were plagiarised from a story from a little-known British author.
The suit filed in New York against the publisher of the JK Rowling books had argued the stories were inspired by Adrian Jacobs’s The Adventures of Willy the Wizard No.1 Livid Land, published in 1987.
Judge Shira Sheindlin wrote that there were major differences between the works, contrary to claims that Rowling had borrowed from Jacobs’ book for Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.
“Indeed, a reading of the works unequivocally confirms that they are distinctly different in both substance and style, and ultimately engender very different visceral responses from their readers,” the Daily Telegraph quoted the judge as saying in a 49-page ruling.
“The contrast between the total concept and feel of the works is so stark that any serious comparison of the two strains credulity.”
Scholastic, the US publisher for the Potter series, said it was satisfied by the dismissal of the suit from the estate of Jacobs.
“The court’s swift dismissal supports our position that the case was completely without merit and that comparing Willy the Wizard to the Harry Potter series was absurd,” company spokesman Kyle Good said.
“Judge Scheindlin clearly agreed … Scholastic will continue to vigorously defend any such frivolous claims challenging the originality of Harry Potter and the brilliant imagination of its author, JK Rowling,” Good added. (ANI)
- J.K Rowling 'Harry Potter' Plagiarism Dismissed in US - Jan 08, 2011
- Rowling's 'plagiarism' case to include US publishers - Jul 15, 2010
- J K Rowling embroiled in 'Harry Potter' plagiarism row - Oct 15, 2010
- 'Harry Potter' author Rowling vows to battle plagiarism charge - Feb 19, 2010
- Harry Potter publisher blasts plagiarism claims over Goblet Of Fire - Jun 16, 2009
- JK Rowling slams Harry Potter plagiarism charges - Feb 18, 2010
- JK Rowling slams plagiarism claims - Feb 19, 2010
- No more Harry Potter books: Daniel Radcliffe - Nov 17, 2010
- Radcliffe wants to play superhero - May 26, 2012
- Daniel Radcliffe: No More Potter Movie Without J K Rowling Book - Nov 30, 2010
- Harry Potter series 'inspiring fans to create their own art' - Nov 14, 2010
- Rowling doesn't rule out more Harry Potter books - Oct 03, 2010
- Daniel Radcliffe 'was worried about new Potter book rumours' - Apr 27, 2011
- Rowling plans 'Harry Potter' encyclopaedia - Apr 18, 2012
- J.K. Rowling sued for plagiarism - Jun 16, 2009
Tags: british author, company spokesman, credulity, daily telegraph, federal judge, frivolous claims, goblet of fire, harry potter, harry potter and the goblet, harry potter and the goblet of fire, harry potter series, jacobs, jk rowling, judge scheindlin, originality, plagiarism suit, scholastic, shira sheindlin, strains, willy the wizard