Supreme Court frowns upon ‘Jana Gana Mana Rann’ (Lead)May 25th, 2009 - 7:37 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, May 25 (IANS) The Supreme Court Monday disapproved of the controversial song “Jana Gana Mana Rann” in director Ram Gopal Varma’s new film “Rann”, saying nobody has the right to tinker with the national anthem.
A vacation bench of Justice V.S. Sirpurkar and Justice R.M. Lodha said this while hearing a lawsuit by the director challenging the denial of permission for exhibition of a promotional film for the song, which is based on India’s national anthem “Jana Gana Mana”.
“We have read it (the script of the song). It gives a total negative sense. It appears that every line of the national anthem has been proved wrong,” said the bench.
“Nobody has got the right to tinker with the national anthem,” the bench observed, while denying any prompt legal relief to Varma against the May 8 order of the Central Film Certification Board.
The board had denied Varma the permission for release of the promo on the grounds that the song, “Jana Gana Mana Rann”, had distorted and tampered with the national anthem.
Refusing to grant any urgent legal relief to the film director, the bench told him to first approach the appellate tribunal, set up under the Cinematography Act, 1952 to challenge the board’s decision.
The bench also asked the tribunal to decide on Varma’s lawsuit challenging the board’s decision within a month and subsequently asked the film director to come back to it if he was not satisfied with the appellate tribunal’s ruling.
Appearing for Varma, senior counsel Arun Jaitley sought scrapping of the board’s decision, contending that it has prompted various television channels to not show the promo.
Jaitley contended that the board’s decision has made even mobile telephone service providers averse to uploading the song as caller tunes for fear of insulting the national anthem.
In his lawsuit, Varma contended that the “Jana Gana Mana Rann” song in his film merely uses the national anthem in a respectful manner for the purpose of artistic expression.
He said the issue involves a citizens’ fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression.
Jaitley argued that if the film song could be misconstrued as showing disrespect to the national anthem, then the flag of various political parties too would be regarded as no lesser an insult to the national flag.
He said after all the flags of parties like the Congress, Nationalist Congress Party and Trinamool Congress bear a striking similarity to the national flag barring their central symbols.
But the court did not appear to be convinced by his argument.
- Supreme Court directs Censor Board to solve Rann's issue case within a month - May 25, 2009
- Varma replaces 'Jana Gana' with 'Vande Mataram' in 'Rann' - Dec 07, 2009
- National anthem becomes disabled-friendly - Dec 27, 2011
- Apex court asks Ram Gopal Varma to approach tribunal for movie - May 25, 2009
- Ram Gopal Varma hasn't done anything punishable, say lawyers - May 20, 2009
- Amitabh, Ram Gopal Varma burnt in effigy for 'twisting' national anthem - May 09, 2009
- 'Rann' director to move apex court against censor ruling - May 13, 2009
- India's national anthem completes a century (Lead) - Dec 27, 2011
- Ram Gopal Varma twists national anthem for 'Rann' (With Images) - May 06, 2009
- Indian national anthem completes 100 years - Dec 27, 2011
- Freedom is remote-controlled in India: Filmmaker Varma - Jan 22, 2010
- 'Rann' of business and conscience in media (IANS Preview) - Jan 26, 2010
- 'Agyaat' smoking scene cut for TV: Ram Gopal Varma - Jul 26, 2009
- India was undecided about national anthem at Independence - Sep 01, 2012
- Music Review of Rann (2010) - Jan 16, 2010
Tags: appellate tribunal, bench, caller tunes, cinematography, controversial song, film certification, film director, first approach, jana gana mana, lodha, mobile telephone, national anthem jana gana mana, negative sense, new film, ram gopal varma, rann, respectful manner, senior counsel, telephone service providers, television channels