‘Red Riding Hood’ attempts another ‘Twilight’ (IANS Movie Review)March 19th, 2011 - 4:11 pm ICT by IANS
Film: “Red Riding Hood”; Director: Catherine Hardwicke; Cast: Amanda Seyfried, Gary Oldman, Billy Burke, Shiloh Fernandez, Max Irons; Rating: ***
With the global popularity of “Twilight”, director Catherine Hardwicke has become a hot commodity. Sadly, the franchise decided to go the “Harry Potter” way and have a new director direct each film. The result? Catherine returns, and attempts to create another “Twilight” with her next film, but only with partial success.
In simple terms, “Red Riding Hood” is the teenage adaptation of the children’s fable by the same name where a wolf impersonates a little girl’s grandmother to eat both up.
A medieval village has been plagued by a werewolf that rises during full moon night for generations. Peace has been maintained as the village offers the werewolf its best animals. However, when Valerie’s (Seyfried) sister is murdered, the villagers are terrified.
Valerie finds herself at the centre of the drama involving her two suitors Peter (Fernandez) and Henry (Irons) even as Father Solomon (Oldman), known for slaying werewolves, comes to the village to save them. Solomon explains that the wolf is amidst them in human form. As the search expands, Valerie finds herself suspecting everyone - from her family to her lovers and her friends. Who is the wolf and what does it want from Valerie?
Though predictable for discerning viewers, the film does manage to keep the suspense going and round it up convincingly in the end. The problem, however, is in its intention.
Director Catherine Hardwicke obviously wanted to recreate the “Twilight” magic. However, despite getting a good lead in Amanda Seyfried, her choice of male leads lets the film down. Neither do they have the cuteness factor of the two leads in “Twilight”, nor is it a broody teenage-angst story to allow for this discrepancy. The story has to rely on the suspense, which does manage to hold attention.
The idea, as you will figure in the end, was to have a movie franchise. The problem with this is that unlike “Twilight”, which is primarily a love story, this one’s a thriller which hinges on suspense. A sequel, if any, will have viewers expecting the same and to turn it into a love story now would perhaps be ill-advised.
Also unlike “Twilight”, the film uses very crude and un-cinematic techniques to tell different stories, like the irritating way of using dialogues to do the same instead of showing or implying it. There is no time here for cinematic enunciations or creation of mood that jars an otherwise credible story.
- I want to be like Meryl Streep: Amanda Seyfried - Jul 08, 2010
- Amanda Seyfried says she's most comfortable when she's naked - Mar 13, 2011
- Amanda Seyfried's 'nude phone interview' with Justin Timberlake - Feb 21, 2011
- Amanda Seyfried 'insults' Leonardo Dicaprio by suggesting dad's role - Jun 12, 2010
- 'Twilight' director to auction Bella's bed - Jun 15, 2011
- Amanda Seyfried hopes her performance is 'respected' - Apr 10, 2011
- Seyfried insults DiCaprio - Jun 12, 2010
- Rob Pattinson could be dating Kristen Stewart - Jun 09, 2009
- Amanda Seyfried to play the role of Linda Lovelace in biopic - Jan 04, 2012
- New dolls on Pattinson, Stewart 'Twilight' wedding - Jan 12, 2012
- Kristen Stewart fell in 'love at first sight' with Robert Pattinson - Mar 04, 2011
- Seyfried has crush on Timberlake - Nov 02, 2011
- Parker likely to replace Demi in 'Lovelace' - Jan 30, 2012
- Is Ryan Phillippe, Amanda Seyfried's romance back on track? - Mar 12, 2011
- Kristen Stewart named World's Best Young Actress - Jun 08, 2010
Tags: amanda seyfried, catherine hardwicke, cuteness factor, discerning viewers, discrepancy, fable, full moon night, gary oldman, global popularity, irons, medieval village, partial success, peter fernandez, red riding hood, shiloh fernandez, suitors, teenage angst, twilight magic, werewolf, werewolves