Ram Gopal Varma hasn’t done anything punishable, say lawyersMay 20th, 2009 - 10:17 am ICT by IANS
By Radhika Bhirani
New Delhi, May 20 (IANS) Director Ram Gopal Varma has irked the censor board by tampering with the national anthem for the song “Jana gana mana rann hai” in his upcoming film “Rann” which stars megastar Amitabh Bachchan. Lawyers say there is no specific law to prevent people from doing so.
“There can’t be anything disparaging on the national anthem or flag or any such property. One can’t play around with these things. But sadly, no legal action against any person can be taken if he or she tampers with the anthem because there is no law for it,” Lalit Bhasin, president of the Society of Indian Law Firms, told IANS.
According to the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971, a person could be charged with a criminal offence with regard to the national anthem only if he or she “intentionally prevents the singing of the Indian national anthem or causes disturbances to any assembly engaged in such singing”.
Bhasin also said that nothing can be done to prevent Varma from using the anthem under the existing law.
Varma faced the ire of protesters and a ban on the song by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) after he showcased the first look of “Rann” last week. But the filmmaker maintains it does not portray the national anthem in bad light.
“Through this song, we are talking about the (ongoing) disputes in the country but there were no intentions to ridicule anything. It’s something I felt in my heart and it was my idea to place the song like this. It is based on the script of my film and I don’t think there’s any offence in it,” Varma had said.
The promo, however, led to protesters burning effigies of Varma and Bachchan in Mumbai and Ranchi last week.
A Lok Janshakti Party (LJP) leader, who was among the 100-odd protesters in Ranchi, had said: “We cannot tolerate twisting of the national song. It is dishonour of the national song and the country. We are planning to file public interest litigation in the Jharkhand High Court seeking banning of the movie.”
But such acts of protest are futile, say lawyers.
“I don’t see why justice is going to the roads. When there is no punishment for the act according to the law, nothing can be done about it. I have heard the song and there is no dishonour to the national anthem,” said Supreme Court lawyer Pinki Anand.
“Freedom of speech and expression is a fundamental right of every Indian citizen. And when there is no system of law against what the filmmaker has done, no amount of people taking to the roads and agitation can help,” she added.
Jayant Bhushan, a senior advocate, echoed similar sentiments and said: “Freedom of speech is important. One shouldn’t be too sensitive. I don’t think the filmmaker has dented the national anthem by just changing a few lines. The dignity of the national anthem is not so fragile.”
Varma is now moving Supreme Court after the censor board refused permission to air the song, said producer Madhu Mantena.
However, Lalit Bhasin said that the CBFC can ban either a part or the entire film “if its content is socially misgiving and creates unrest among people”.
“But if the filmmakers are going to appeal to the court, only the judges will have the final say,” he said.
(Radhika Bhirani can be contacted at email@example.com)
- Freedom is remote-controlled in India: Filmmaker Varma - Jan 22, 2010
- 'Rann' of business and conscience in media (IANS Preview) - Jan 26, 2010
- 'Rann' director to move apex court against censor ruling - May 13, 2009
- Varma replaces 'Jana Gana' with 'Vande Mataram' in 'Rann' - Dec 07, 2009
- Supreme Court lifts Uttar Pradesh ban on 'Aarakshan' (Lead) - Aug 19, 2011
- 'Discourage glamorisation of smoking' - Feb 02, 2012
- Censor Trouble For Ram Gopal Varma's 'Rakhta Charitra' - Oct 16, 2010
- New film classification system to replace censorship: Samson - Jun 15, 2011
- 'Jism 2' for common man who understands erotica: Pooja - Jul 19, 2012
- I'm an attention seeker: Ram Gopal Varma (Interview) - Aug 07, 2009
- Apex court asks Ram Gopal Varma to approach tribunal for movie - May 25, 2009
- Bollywood now high on drug tales - Apr 21, 2011
- Apex court pulls up Tamil Nadu on film ban - Jan 13, 2012
- Sex comedy in B-town: Audiences ready, censors alert - Jul 23, 2012
- Supreme Court directs Censor Board to solve Rann's issue case within a month - May 25, 2009
Tags: amitabh bachchan, cbfc, criminal offence, effigies, film certification, filmmaker, indian law firms, indian national anthem, insults, jana gana mana, ljp, lok, mumbai, national honour, New Delhi, protesters, ram gopal varma, rann, tampers, upcoming film