‘Minchina Ota’ - a mediocre fare by director Ramesh (Kannada Film Review)July 12th, 2008 - 9:59 am ICT by IANS
By R.G. Vijayasarathy
Film: “Minchina Ota”; Cast: Vijaya Raghavendra, Sree Murali, Lakshmi Rai, Suman, Rahul Roy and others; Story-Screenplay-Direction: M.R. Ramesh; Music Director: V. Manohar; Cinemetography: P. Rajan; Rating: ** A guy living in a Bangalore slum is always at crossroads with a neighbourhood rich guy. And both of them fall in love with the same girl. But the girl, sister of a don, chooses the poorer man - the story may sound interesting, but the film “Minchina Ota” is not.
Inspired by Hollywood director Steven Spielberg’s classic telefilm “Duel”, “Minchina Ota” certainly fails to recreate the same magic.
Made in 1971, Spielberg’s “Duel” was a taut thriller and received special praise for its edge of the seat narration. But the commercial elements in “Minchina Ota” have failed to gel with the action scenes.
Except for a few moments of excitement in the second half, the film’s narration is not fast-paced. This is the main drawback of the movie.
Director M.R. Ramesh, who had earlier shown a lot of promise in award-winning films like “Cyanide”, has disappointed fans by dishing out such an ordinary fare.
He has failed to deliver what he had promised before the film’s release. Despite receiving good support from music director V. Manohar and cinematographer P. Rajan, Ramesh has not tuned his script properly.
Another drawback is that the director has included too many elements in the film. And the so-called sentimental sequences in the first half featuring Umashri and Rangayana Raghu clearly become a testing ground for patience.
Vijaya Raghavendra and his brother Sree Murali have acted with conviction, but what can they do if they don’t have a good script to back them.
Lakshmi Rai does not have ample opportunities to prove her talent, but she looks good on screen. Veteran artistes Rangayana Raghu and Umashri have over-acted in their respective roles.
Suman and Rahul Roy play villains in the film.
Tags: ample opportunities, award winning films, commercial elements, director steven spielberg, drawback, hollywood director, lakshmi rai, manohar, mediocre fare, movie director, music director, narration, r ramesh, rahul roy, rajan, slum, sree, steven spielberg, story screenplay, taut thriller