‘Detective Naani’ lazy weekend viewing with kids (IANS Film Review)May 23rd, 2009 - 5:49 pm ICT by IANS
By Joginder Tuteja
Film: “Detective Naani”; Director: Romilla Mukherjee; Cast: Ava Mukherjee, Zain Khan, Simran Singh, Shweta Gulati, Amit Varma, Amrita Saluja, Ankur Nayyar and Hemu Adhikarie; Rating: **
As the title suggests, “Detective Naani” is a simple story about a granny (Ava Mukherjee) who has those intrinsic detective traits to her. She may not be trained like the CID officers she comes in contact with as the story progresses, and nor is she expected to be physically agile like youngsters.
Still, this 75-year-old lady has decades of experience behind her and a ’strong instinct’ factor that makes her see things that others may ignore.
This is where the film’s basic plot comes into the picture as ‘naani’ suspects something fishy going on in her neighbourhood. She has a strong reason to believe that children in her locality are going missing. But no one wants to believe her. Her approaching the cops too proves to be futile and it is left entirely to her to get her own team - a bunch of youngsters, her grandchildren and a few other friendly neighbourhood folks - together and solve the mystery.
But this journey to the bottom takes its own time and it does become a little tiring intermittently. All you want to know is the ‘what’, ‘who’, ‘where’ and ‘why’ behind the mysterious happenings but filmmaker Romilla Mukherjee brings in other Bollywood masala elements to overtly dramatise the affair.
However, as is a mandatory requirement of any suspense flick, the end should keep you interested in the proceedings and this is what happens in case of “Detective Naani” as well. After a good beginning and an average middle portion, the last few reels manage to pull back the movie, saving it from being an entirely lame exercise.
What impresses most about the movie are the tricks that ‘naani’ applies to find the culprits. The clues that she detects to move a step ahead may not be the kind that one finds in the theory book, but they have a practical touch to them.
From the performance standpoint, the film was meant to be the ‘naani’ affair all the way and Ava Mukherjee doesn’t disappoint. Though a known face on the commercial circuit, she has been doing films only sparsely - she was earlier seen in “Darna Zaroori Hai” and “Devdas”. “Detective Naani” is the first time that she has been seen as a protagonist in a Bollywood flick.
Ankur Nayyar as the CID officer does quite well too though he comes with the disadvantage of appearing in a film where he primarily has a supporting role.
The film’s music is boring, though the background score is reasonably good.
It’s easy to dismiss a film based on just the title, genre and the star cast. The same applies to “Detective Naani”, which arrives sans any promotion, has unknown faces and isn’t quite forthcoming of its genre - is it comedy, a family film or a thriller?
But if one keeps all these aside and focuses just on the story and its execution, it’s not a bad watch at all. “Detective Naani”, which has first-timer Romilla Mukherjee taking up the multiple responsibilities of a producer, director, lyricist, composer and screenplay writer, isn’t the summer kiddie flick that you were waiting for.
Still, if you have absolutely nothing else to watch and are through with your daily dose of IPL, “Detective Naani” is all right for lazy weekend viewing.
- Movie Review: Detective Naani - May 22, 2009
- Out with Daadi, in with Naani -Ava Mukherjee - May 14, 2009
- DIRECTING "DETECTIVE NAANI"-Romilla Mukherjee - May 14, 2009
- 'Cowboys and Aliens' an adrenaline rush (IANS Film Review) - Jul 30, 2011
- Moubani Sorcar Wants To Take A Break To Return With A Bang! - Jan 06, 2011
- "I Genuinely Feel That I Want To Be In A Bigger League Than Aishwarya Rai And Kareena Kapoor, Because I Feel That I Deserve It And It Is Just A Question Of Being At The Right Place At The Right Time" - Sheena Nayyar - Sep 03, 2010
- Imran Khan: All Set To Take On challenging Roles - Nov 27, 2010
- Review 3: Hisss (2010) - Oct 23, 2010
- 'The Forest' terrorises despite the cliche (IANS MOvie Review) - May 11, 2012
- Youth will like classical music; just serve it right: Durga Jasraj - Mar 04, 2012
- TV show 'CID' could soon be a film - May 30, 2012
- 'Ek Tha Tiger': Gripping espionage romp, with unique star chemistry (IANS Hindi Film Review) - Aug 16, 2012
- Witherspoon reads about herself online - Dec 12, 2010
- 'Safe' a safe action ride (IANS Movie Review) - May 05, 2012
- To be a celebrity, be strong: Bipasha - May 17, 2012
Tags: amit varma, amrita saluja, ankur nayyar, cid officers, culprits, hemu, joginder, lazy weekend, mandatory requirement, middle portion, mysterious happenings, naani, old lady, own time, shweta gulati, simran singh, something fishy, theory book, youngsters, zain khan