CWG lyricist fights criticism, says not reworking song
September 3rd, 2010 - 7:26 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Sep 3 (IANS) A.R. Rahman’s theme song for the Commonwealth Games (CWG) “Jiyo Utho Badho Jeeto” has been widely panned as just average, but lyricist Mehboob defends his work and says people forget it’s an anthem and not a commercial Bollywood song.
“We have not received any intimation as far as rework on the song is concerned and I don’t think we need to rework on it,” Mehboob told IANS.
It took Mehboob and Rehman six months to finish the CWG song, which involved a bit of travelling as Rahman sits in Chennai and Mehboob in Mumbai.
“The song is getting mixed reviews but the negative side is being blown out of proportion. People are forgetting it’s an anthem and not a commercial Bollywood song,” said Mehboob.
“Rahman’s song are usually slow to pick up but have a mass appeal to them when they reach the peak. His music is like sweet poison it starts from the ground level and then reaches heights. I’m sure this song will grow, but the public needs to realise it is not a film song.
“Just because it has Rahman, people expect it to be a fast, peppy number but this has serious sentiments attached to it. The song is not based on a particular game, it is for all of them and we are the host, we are inviting 53 countries to our nation. People need to focus on the lyrics and visualise it.”
According to a recent report, former sports minister Shahnawaz Hussain has demanded a re-composition of the theme track.
“I respect Rahman for what he has achieved but the track simply does not excite me. No one in the Organising Committee (OC) likes it except perhaps Suresh Kalmadi. It is nowhere close to ‘Waka Waka’ (Shakira’s hit song for the football World Cup) and has failed to lift the sagging spirits of the CWG,” Hussain was quoted as saying.
“Either it is good music or bad. There is no middle way to evaluate the appeal of a Rs.5 crore (Rs.50 million) track, he can surely re-compose it,” he added.
Many disappointed fans have also posted their reactions on the micro-blogging site Twitter.
“No way near to ‘Waka Waka’. We don’t want classical wizards to compose for sports event. Five crore rupees went down the drain, time also wasted,” a fan posted on Rahman’s Twitter page.
Another fan wrote: “Very average song..Definitely not worth Rs.5 crores.. Poor music is… well…. poor music… irrespective of where it comes from.”
“I love your approach to music and creativity you bring about in the Indian sub-continent. But this composition was for the nation and miss the ‘deep love’ depicting the true soul of India and its rich diverse culture. I dont understand why elements of Rap had to be here at all. It has got nothing to do with the true soul of India,” read another post.
Rahman and Mehboob have earlier collaborated on projects like “Rangeela”, “Bombay”, “Doli Saja Ke Rakhna”, “Daud”, “Yuva” “Thakshak” and “Dil Hi Dil Mein”.
- 'Jiyo utho...' targets young generation: CWG lyricist Mehboob - Sep 01, 2010
- Games anthem now more peppy, shorter, tighter: Prasoon Joshi - Sep 16, 2010
- I hope my song captures unity of FIFA World Cup: singer K'Naan (Interview)(Lead) - Jul 05, 2010
- Games anthem no copy of 'Waka Waka', asserts Benegal - Aug 17, 2010
- Writing World Cup song was an emotional moment: Manoj Yadav (Interview) - Jan 05, 2011
- Somali singer K'Naan strikes a chord with Indians - Jul 05, 2010
- Bollywood remembers Panchamda on his 72nd birth anniversary (June 27 is R.D. Burman's birth anniversary) - Jun 25, 2011
- Rahman asked to tweak CWG theme song (Lead) - Aug 16, 2010
- Anand Raj Anand composes two songs for CWG, to perform at opening ceremony - Sep 21, 2010
- Composer duo Anand-Milind back - Apr 25, 2012
- Aamir prepares for Toronto film fest (Movie Snippets) - Sep 07, 2010
- Shakira: Shining With Nokia’s Ovi Music Numero Uno Spot - Jan 17, 2011
- Rahman shoots promotional video for film - Jan 25, 2012
- I dedicate my CWG song to sportsmen: Kailash Kher - Sep 24, 2010
- Shaan brings Kishore Kumar's melodies alive - Mar 26, 2012
Tags: bollywood song, commonwealth games, crore, film song, football world cup, former sports, good music, hussain, intimation, jeeto, lyricist, mass appeal, mehboob, organising committee, rs 50, s song, shahnawaz, shakira, sweet poison, utho