‘Aloo Chaat’ is neither funny nor new (IANS Film Review, Rating: *1/2)March 24th, 2009 - 3:12 pm ICT by IANS
By Subhash K. Jha
Film: “Aloo Chat”; Director: Robbie Grewal; Cast: Aftab Shivdasani, Amna Sharif, Linda Arsenio; Rating: *1/2
“Do you have a boyfriend?” Aftab Shivdasani, dimpling with mischievous intent, asks his prospective bride. “Neither do I!”. Ha ha…
“We could go out at least two evenings every week after marriage,” Aftab promises. “You could go on Saturdays, I on Sundays.”
Ha ha ho ho…
Robbie Grewal’s first cinematic outing “Samay” featured Sushmita Sen as a tough cop and his second feature was a mushy ode to first - “Mera Pehla Pehla Pyar”. This time Grewal falls as flat as a cold chapati while attempting this groom meets bride tale in a Punjabi household bustling with uncles, aunts and other relatives.
Trouble is, we don’t see much of the domestic action jumping out of the screen to claim our attention. The characters including the ever-dependable Kulbhushan Kharbanda behave like a crew from a long-running serial straying into a film about life in a family serial.
Every actor behaves as though he’s playing a part for the camera. The talented Manoj Pahwa playing a tawdry sexologist talks directly into the camera.
Is he the narrator or just the excitable orator? Are we watching a film on contemporary mores as opposed to conventional attitudes? Or is this a script that Basu Chatterjee decided to throw away for its lack of punch?
The plot, if you want to know, is about a Punjabi NRI who, in order to convince his family to let him marry a Muslim girl, brings home a tourist as his girlfriend.
“Thank God he didn’t bring home a guy,” someone quips as this bargain basement version of “Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge” chugs along at a dull though inoffensive pace.
“Aloo Chaat” is a Punjabi comedy that you’ve been seeing on television for years and is now being screened on a much larger screen and a far smaller intellectual level.
Aftab Shivdasani and Amna Sharif share some watchable moments together. But these moments are squandered in the wrong movie with the wrong plot.
- Movie Review : Aloo Chaat (2009) - Mar 20, 2009
- Comedy isn't my favourite genre: Aftab Shivdasani - Feb 13, 2009
- NO TV SERIALS FOR ME BECAUSE I WANT TO FOCUS ONLY ON FILMS NOW - Mar 21, 2009
- "ALOO CHAAT doesn't move without Linda's character" - Aftab Shivdasani - Mar 17, 2009
- Love without the food of music - 'Aloo Chat' crew shows how - Mar 20, 2009
- Punjabis dominate Bollywood releases this season - Mar 19, 2009
- 'Khushiyaan' selected for Punjabi film fest in Toronto - May 17, 2012
- 'Speedy Singh' - A cliche-loaded NRI tale (IANS Hindi Film Review) - Sep 24, 2011
- Awards don't matter for Aftab Shivdasani - Sep 11, 2009
- Aamna and Aftab's starry ways. - Mar 21, 2009
- Movie Review : Aao Wish Karein (2009) - Nov 13, 2009
- Enough of sequels, comedies for Riteish! - Jun 27, 2012
- Aamna Sharif back on small screen (With Images) - Aug 09, 2012
- SRK apologises to 'Always Kabhi Kabhi' cast (Movie Snippets) - Jun 18, 2011
- When Abhishek Bachchan wanted to sleep with Zeenat Aman (Film Snippets) - Mar 09, 2009
Tags: aftab shivdasani, amna sharif, aunts, bargain basement, chaat, chapati, chatterjee, intellectual level, linda arsenio, manoj, mores, muslim girl, narrator, nri, orator, pehla pehla, pehla pyar, prospective bride, subhash k jha, sushmita sen