Aishwarya

‘3 Idiots’ totally different from ‘Five Point Someone’: Sharman Joshi

December 24th, 2009 - 8:34 pm ICT by IANS ( 7 comments )

Aamir Khan New Delhi, Dec 24 (IANS) If you thought Rajkumar Hirani’s “3 Idiots” was a cover to cover adaptation of Chetan Bhagat’s bestseller “Five Point Someone”, Bollywood actor Sharman Joshi would disagree. Joshi, who stars in the film, says it has no resemblance to the book in terms of the story.
“‘3 Idiots’ is based on Chetan Bhagat’s ‘Five Point Someone’ but it’s not the book that you want to see in the form of a film when you go out. There are only a few points from the book in the film. Otherwise it’s a totally different screenplay and story,” Sharman told IANS on phone from Mumbai.

“‘Five Point Someone’ was an extremely popular book and loved by people and so it is very important for people to know that it’s not the book they are going to go out and see. It (the movie) is very different from what the book was,” he added.

Sharman stressed on the differences between the book and the movie and said: “There are three guys who are studying in an engineering college and there is a love interest as it is based on Chetan Bhagat’s book and so he has been given the credit for that. But the story is completely different.”

Releasing Friday, “3 Idiots” has been produced by Vidhu Vinod Chopra and stars Aamir Khan and R. Madhavan alongside Sharman. Kareena Kapoor and Boman Irani also play pivotal roles in the comic-drama.

Throwing light on his character, Sharman said: “My character’s name is Raju Rastogi. He is brilliant at what he does which is engineering. He comes from a very humble background as his father is a postman.

“Because he is doing well academically they start building hopes that he will pull them out of poverty and help them enjoy the pleasures of life. And it is because of this pressure that he is not able to live his life,” he added.

Noteworthy is the predominant ‘Idiot’ tag in the film despite it being about engineering students.

Sharman explained: “The way we are interpreting idiots is quite different from what the dictionary meaning of idiots is. Our interpretation of idiots is someone who follows one’s own heart and who probably goes against the norms because it is something he believes in. And ‘I Did It On my Terms’ is the full form of it.”

Sharman agreed that “3 Idiots” also carries a predominant message like Chopra and Hirani’s earlier ventures — “Munnabhai M.B.B.S” and “Lage Raho Munna Bhai”.

“Sure, it has. It’s narrated in a lighter way and there are moments which are rather dramatic. There are things which can fundamentally change the way you think. I hope it goes across to the people and they appreciate it,” he said.

The actor was also ecstatic about having re-teamed with Aamir and Madhavan for the movie after “Rang De Basanti”.

“It (the experience) has been special again. We partied last on the sets of ‘Rang De Basanti’ and continued it on the sets of ‘3 Idiots’,” he said.

“We all get along very well and the bond is hardly worked uponÂ… It just kind of flows and we’ve shared a lot of special moments. We had a great time working on the film.”

Sharman’s future projects include “Toh Baat Pakki” and “Allah Ke Bande”, both slated for release early next year.

He is also hoping for more offers after “3 Idiots”.

“I have been reading about two to three scripts a week and I hope the number goes up to six to eight,” he said.

Related Stories

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Posted in Entertainment |

7 Responses

  1. Neha Says:

    Sharman is wrong, the movie is completely based on that novel except ending and that was requirement for bollywood masala movie. I have read that novel and when I was watching this movie, I couldn’t control me to resemble with novel. I agreed with Sharman that book and movie can not be same, they must have difference.

  2. Dhaynik Modi Says:

    We think that Aamir has to clearly recognise and admit that the whole story / idea / premise / concept for 3 idiots has been taken from chetan’s five point someone - period. These denials from the film camp are looking increasingly sheepish now, as they try and take credit for someone else’s idea. The story was by chetan bhagat, and he should’ve been appropriately credited for it at the start of the movie the same way the producer, director, musicians etc. have been.

    Let’s not forget, this isn’t the first time Aamir has tried to wrestle credit from someone else, how can we forget Taare Zameen Par, where AK ousted Amole Gupte after effectively stealing his story, ideas, and finally - the directing credit. He accuses Chetan of seeking publicity / wanting to sell more books.. this might have been believable, had he not been India’s largest selling English-language author.

    Abhijat and Raju Hirani have adapted Chetan’s FPS, they need to give credit where credit is due. Come on guys, have some integrity!

  3. kapil Says:

    movie is definitely based on five point someone. you can not take credit the brilliance of chetan. anybody who has read the book previously can easily identify the soul, although the there are cosmetic surgery has been done.

  4. veera Says:

    i agree with you all 3 idiot is not original……………….

  5. Brijesh Says:

    There is no doubt that the core idea of the movie “3-idiots” is copied from chetan’s novel “five points someone”. but why chetan is raising this issue as there were no such contract or legal papers signed with chetan by the raj hirani or the director of the movie that ” the name of chetan bhagat, they are going to put in the list of script-writer” .

    so i thinks, chetan had to think it previouly before signing the copy-right papers/ contract between producer n chetan “that i want my name in the list of script-writers”

    if this much care had been taken by chetan at the time of signing of contract then this big mesh has not happened.

  6. purple Says:

    why chetan is doing all this dramas. the movie is hit becoz of film makers and actors. before this movie nobody knew about the book now why chetan is trying to be a hero from zero pulling others lets. whtever the book is i love the movie n i will give credit for movie makers.

  7. sneha Says:

    The movie 3 idiots is based on the novel “5 point someone”. I have read the novel. The movie is copied from the novel except ending…

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.


RSS feed for comments on ‘3 Idiots’ totally different from ‘Five Point Someone’: Sharman Joshi