Privacy disappearing due to technology: Supreme Court (Lead)February 24th, 2011 - 11:18 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, Feb 24 (IANS) The Supreme Court Thursday said that with the march of technology, privacy is “virtually disappearing”.”Given the technological advancement, privacy is virtually disappearing,” said a bench of Justice G.S. Singhvi and A.K. Ganguly.
The court’s observation came in the wake of senior counsel Harish Salve’s submission that if the government had the right to snoop on the citizen’s privacy (through phonetaps) in the national interest, then it also had a corresponding responsibility of guarding these intercepts from public gaze.
Salve was arguing for Tata Group chairperson Ratan Tata seeking a thorough probe into the leaking of corporate lobbyist Niira Radia’s taped conversations related to 2G spectrum allocation. Tata figured in some of the conversations.
Radia’s telephones were put under surveillance after the home ministry received a letter alleging that in a short period of few years, she had amassed huge wealth and that she had foreign connections.
The court also observed that the “Official Secrets Act is a very old act and it guards the privacy of Indian citizens, while it may need reform”.
The original copy of the letter received by the ministry was placed before the court.
Referring to the government’s stance that it was investigating the source of the leak of the Radia tapes, Salve told the court that there was nothing in the actions of the government that showed that it was seriously pursuing the matter.
The apex court was told that it was incumbent upon the agencies involved in wire-tapping to immediately destroy those portions of intercepts that were not required by them.
He said that if the government was at all serious about maintaining the confidentiality of the Radia tapes then it should have got alerted April 28, 2010 when excerpts of these appeared in print.
The senior counsel told the court that the Radia tapes have nothing to do with 2G spectrum controversies as the licences were allocated to telecom companies in January 2008 whereas her phones’ tapping commenced in August 2008.
Analysing the affidavit filed by the central government in December last year, Salve said that information about Radia tapes was available with three intelligence agencies. The fourth entity that could be privy to such tapping was the service provider.
Salve told the court that being a licensed service provider of the central government, the nodal officer (of the private service provider) comes in the category of public person and is liable for prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act for wrongdoings.
- Technology diluting privacy: Supreme Court - Feb 24, 2011
- Tata seeks report on leaked Radia tapes (Lead) - Feb 02, 2012
- Spell out steps to plug leakage of phone taps: SC (Lead) - Aug 28, 2012
- Leaked Radia tapes doctored, apex court told (Lead) - Jan 31, 2012
- Source of Radia tapes' leak unknown, court told - Aug 23, 2012
- Source of Radia tapes' leak unknown, court told (Lead) - Aug 23, 2012
- On Tata's plea, apex court sends notice to government - Dec 02, 2010
- Supreme Court issues notices to government on Tata's plea (Lead) - Dec 02, 2010
- Tata's privacy plea to be heard in February, claims rebutted - Dec 13, 2010
- Leaked Radia tapes doctored, government tells SC - Jan 31, 2012
- 2G scam: Supreme Court to take up Ratan Tata's petition - Dec 02, 2010
- Ratan Tata moves court against publication on Radia tapes (Lead) - Nov 29, 2010
- Spell out steps to plug leakage of phone taps: SC - Aug 28, 2012
- Home Ministry asks IB, CBDT to probe Radia tape leakages - Nov 29, 2010
- Supreme Court to hear Ratan Tata plea to stop Radia tapes - Apr 01, 2011
Tags: apex, apex court, controversies, corporate lobbyist, ganguly, group chairperson, home ministry, indian citizens, intercepts, national interest, New Delhi, official secrets, public gaze, radia, ratan tata, secrets act, senior counsel, spectrum allocation, tata group, technological advancement