Mineral water companies asked to fix price at Rs.12March 20th, 2009 - 8:57 pm ICT by IANS
New Delhi, March 20 (IANS) A consumer court Friday directed the authorities and manufacturers of mineral water, who have prescribed the maximum retail price (MRP) at Rs. 20 or higher a bottle, to reduce it to Rs.12 as charging a higher price amounts to unfair trade practice.
The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, headed by Justice J.D. Kapoor, rejected the manufacturer’s plea that the price of Rs.20 for the Himalaya brand mineral water was due to the water being from springs in the Himalayas while other mineral waters brands used water taken from borewells.
“It is immaterial whether mineral water is obtained directly from springs or through any other source. The process of converting ordinary water into mineral water is the same and the quality or purity is also the same,” Justice Kapoor said.
The product should have not been called “mineral water” and sold by another name like “spring water”, as otherwise it gave an impression that the product is mineral water and mislead an ordinary customer as to why it is priced much higher than the other brands available in the market, he said.
Justice Kapoor said if there are 50 brands of mineral water and each brand is said to be a different kind, nature, quality, potency and purity and, therefore, can be priced differently, would be an entirely misleading representation to the public at large.
The case dates back to 2007 when Virender Singh, a resident of Rohini, had gone to Liberty Cinema in Karol Bagh area to watch a film. During the interval, he bought a bottle of mineral water but felt he was overcharged for it. Feeling cheated, he filed a complaint in the consumer court.
- Diane Von Furstenberg to create Evian bottle - Jul 24, 2012
- Liquor shops closed in Jharkhand to protest VAT - Jul 01, 2010
- NourishCo hopes for Rs.700 crore business - Feb 10, 2012
- Coca Cola embroiled in 'dangerously misleading' water ad controversy - Feb 05, 2011
- Women-driven natural cosmetics finds growing takers - Jul 25, 2010
- Punjab on a 'high', to guzzle over 350 mn liquor bottles - Feb 27, 2011
- Nearly half of Pakistanis drinking unsafe water - Mar 22, 2011
- British Indian woos young professionals with trendy jewellery - Oct 02, 2011
- Hike in iron ore export duty irks Goa mining industry - Jan 04, 2012
- Checks on to ensure water quality: Delhi Jal Board - Jun 20, 2011
- McDonald's pulled up for overcharging on cold drink bottle - Oct 05, 2008
- Ensure transparency in tariff ads, TRAI tells operators - Mar 26, 2012
- West Bengal to provide Rs.33 crore fertilizer subsidy - Aug 26, 2011
- When it's about drinking water, Maoists help government - Mar 11, 2012
- Not a rupee more! - Aug 13, 2011
Tags: authorities, consumer disputes, delhi state, himalayas, interval, karol bagh, kind nature, mineral water, mineral waters, misleading representation, mrp, New Delhi, plea, potency, purity, retail price, spring water, unfair trade practice, virender, water companies