Lawsuit challenges SBI’s life insurance scheme
November 26th, 2010 - 8:18 pm ICT by IANS
Lucknow, Nov 26 (IANS) The Lucknow bench of the Allahabad High Court Friday issued a notice to SBI (State Bank of India) Life Insurance on a public interest litigation (PIL), challenging the firm’s scheme of deducting a hefty premium against any housing loan taken from the bank.
Seeking the court issue a writ of mandamus to the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) for cancelling the agency license issued to SBI Life Insurance, the lawsuit contended that such a scheme was being carried out in blatant violation of Section 4 B of the Insurance Act, 1938.
Advocate Dhruv Kumar in his petition sought to draw the court’s attention to the fact that the SBI was not only the promoter of SBI Life Insurance but was also working as an “agent” of its own insurance subsidiary, whose four directors were substantive officials of the SBI.
Issuing notice to the insurance company, a bench of Justice Pradeep Kant and Justice Rituraj Awasthi raised specific query - whether the State Bank of India was an agent of SBI Life or not?
counsel for the bank prayed for some time, following which the court gave him two weeks’ time to file a counter-affidavit.
Earlier, while arguing the case, Dhruv Kumar alleged that SBI, being an agent of its own company, was exploiting the borrowers of the bank and a “predatory priced” policy is being sold by the bank.
He cited a case where a sum of Rs.436,000 was suo moto deducted by the bank as premium without even seeking the consent of the loan applicant. He also cited that insurance for the same amount of a housing loan could be obtained directly from SBI Life Insurance for a premium of just Rs.180,000.
Dhruv Kumar claimed that SBI Life Insurance was responsible for duping more than 15,000 borrowers in this manner.
- Can SBI be an agent of its insurance subsidiary? - Dec 16, 2010
- IRDA fines SBI Life Insurance Rs.70 lakh - Jul 09, 2011
- Draft norms for merger of non-life insurers announced - Feb 10, 2011
- Insurance regulator bracing for spat with judiciary - Feb 14, 2011
- IRDA asks life insurers to defy SEBI ban (Lead) - Apr 11, 2010
- Regulators' tussle leaves life insurers worried - Apr 11, 2010
- SEBI order on ULIPs a wake-up call for IRDA - Apr 12, 2010
- IRDA is micro managing life insurers: Experts - Jul 19, 2010
- Insurance regulator tightens norms on equity-linked plans - May 04, 2010
- Life insurance firms mull riders to take policyholders for a ride - Aug 01, 2010
- Non-life insurers' merger norms discriminatory: Experts - Jun 12, 2011
- IRDA move will kill variable insurance segment: Industry - Oct 23, 2010
- Life insurers asked to defy SEBI ban - Apr 11, 2010
- SBI reduces educational loan rates by up to 1 percent - Feb 27, 2012
- Court bars foreign insurer's agent from selling policies - Sep 26, 2010
Tags: allahabad high court, awasthi, bank of india, blatant violation, housing loan, insurance act 1938, insurance company, insurance regulatory and development authority, insurance scheme, insurance subsidiary, irda, loan applicant, own insurance, pradeep, public interest litigation, rs 180, sbi, state bank, state bank of india, writ of mandamus