Indian Army bought faulty ammunition: Auditor
July 10th, 2009 - 8:02 pm ICT by IANSNew Delhi, July 10 (IANS) The Indian Army flouted norms by placing a repeat order for artillery shells that had been found defective a decade ago, India’s audit watchdog says.
“Krasnopol ammunition costing Rs.375 crore ($76 million) was accepted without necessary trial evaluation. The ammunition proved unsuccessful subsequently,” the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) said in his report released Friday.
“The same ammunition procured earlier in 1999 at the cost of Rs.151 crore was also found unfit for use after seven years against the shelf life of 15 years. Such procurement of defective quality ammunition adversely impacts operational preparedness of the army,” the report added.
Krasnopol shells are fired from the army’s 155 mm howitzers that are used in both offensive and defensive roles.
The defective ammunition had found mention in earlier CAG reports too, but the Indian Army went ahead to buy it in 1999 due to the “operational urgency” of the Kargil conflict that year. The shells were found to have limitations of range, angle and precision in high altitudes.
“During 2006, when confirmatory firing was carried out to assess the performance of the ammunition held in stock, all the six rounds fired blind. The confirmatory firing showed that the ammunition had degraded within half its shelf life of 15 years,” the CAG report pointed out.
The manufacturer was asked to rectify the defects but this was yet to be done as of September 2008.
A repeat order for the ammunition was placed in 2002 without any trial evaluation, the CAG noted.
“Though the initial procurement of 1,000 shells in 2000 might have been on grounds of operational urgency, the subsequent procurement of another 2,000 shells in 2002 without any trial evaluation was incorrect and against procurement norms,” the audit report said.
“As a result, the same limitation of the ammunition in high altitude persisted in the second consignment also. Thus, 3,000 rounds of ammunition worth Rs.526 crore remain unavailable for use,” the report pointed out.
- Not aware of PAC letter over canteen irregularities: Army chief - Jan 06, 2011
- Army, IAF chiefs to appear before PAC over canteen irregularities - Jan 08, 2011
- Aerostat radar damaged, non-operational: Antony - Nov 30, 2011
- CAG raps Indian Navy for buying combat planes sans weapons - Sep 08, 2011
- Army probing leak of howitzer trial report - Feb 14, 2011
- MPs panel dismayed that India can't make warfare clothing - Apr 30, 2010
- Army probing howitzer report leak at highest level: Antony - Feb 15, 2011
- CAG finds 'significant deficiencies' by DDA on CWG - Aug 05, 2011
- 'Irregularity in rural health fund spending in Uttar Pradesh' - Aug 09, 2011
- PAC quizzes army, air force chiefs on canteen irregularities - Jan 12, 2011
- Nobody can manipulate defence deals: Antony (Lead) - Feb 15, 2011
- Nod for official audit of Shimla's prized Wildflower Hall - Jul 15, 2011
- Questions posed by CAG over procurement of sports equipment for CWG - Aug 05, 2011
- Audit finds lapses in defence canteen operations - Aug 13, 2010
- India spent $7 bn on army procurements since 2007 - Dec 21, 2011
Tags: artillery shells, audit report, cag report, comptroller and auditor general, consignment, high altitude, high altitudes, howitzers, indian army, initial procurement, kargil conflict, New Delhi, norms, preparedness, quality ammunition, repeat order, shelf life, trial evaluation, urgency, watchdog