Firm fined Rs.100 crore in Himachal, files review petitionJune 1st, 2012 - 6:10 pm ICT by IANS
Shimla, June 1 (IANS) Just about a month after the Himachal Pradesh High Court directed a private firm to dismantle a thermal power plant in Solan district over green concerns, the company Friday told the court that the project machinery had never been established.
In a review petition placed before the division bench, comprising Justice Deepak Gupta and Justice Sanjay Karol, infrastructure conglomerate Jaiprakash Associates Ltd (JAL) contended that it didn’t install any plant or machinery in the partially constructed civil structure built by it to house the captive thermal power plant (CTTP).
The court, meanwhile, adjourned the hearing to June 15.
In the absence of any plant or machinery, the CTTP has never functioned from its very inception till date and it remains to be a civil structure alone, said the petition.
The high court May 4 observed: “As far as the thermal plant is concerned we find no extenuating circumstances to permit the thermal plant to continue. We accordingly quash the environmental clearance in respect of the thermal plant and direct JAL to dismantle it within three months.”
The company petitioned that in the absence of any machinery or equipment having been installed therein, “the same is incapable of being dismantled”.
“The process of transfer of the plant and machinery brought on the site for the CTPP had already started in November 2011 onwards, since the environment clearance was granted by the ministry of environment and forests only for a 10 MW plant, which was inadequate and was not as per the proposal and requirements (of the company),” said the petition.
The green bench of the high court in its judgment against the cement plant, which existed along with the thermal plant, also imposed a penalty of Rs.100 crore on JAL as environmental damage cost for violation of the norms.
“While assessing the damages, we are also taking into consideration the fact that the damages should not bring the company to a halt but at the same time the company should feel the pinch of damages,” said the court.
“The damages shall be used only for improving the ecology and environment of the area and to ameliorate the sufferings of the people of the area,” the court added.
The company, pleading with the court to recall its order relating to payment of costs imposed on it, said: “Damages have been imposed without granting the petitioner any opportunity before imposition of such heavy damages… the cost of the damage is too harsh, punitive and unbearable and it shall amount to virtually closing down of the industry, which is already suffering from recession.”
- Himachal court dismisses cement firm's petitions - Jul 06, 2012
- Firm fined Rs.100 crore for violating environmental laws - May 04, 2012
- Congress extended favours to Jaiprakash Associates: Dhumal - May 07, 2012
- Blame game over Himachal power plant ordered to be razed - May 20, 2012
- Himachal greens upbeat over 'environmental justice' - May 06, 2012
- Centre ignored protests over cement plant in 2004: Dhumal - May 13, 2012
- No-trust motion against Dhumal defeated in Himachal (Lead) - Aug 29, 2012
- Action only after studying court judgment: Jaiprakash Associates - May 05, 2012
- SC notice on green nod for Maharashtra power project (Lead) - Jun 18, 2012
- Green tribunal scraps Posco's $12bn Odisha project (Second Lead) - Mar 30, 2012
- SC moved for staying Kudankulam's 1989 environmental clearance - Sep 21, 2012
- Green tribunal scraps Posco's $12bn Odisha project (Lead) - Mar 30, 2012
- Andhra High Court dismisses petition against power project - Jul 29, 2010
- Eco concerns land mega Himachal projects in jeopardy - Dec 16, 2010
- Lavasa township project denied environment clearance - Oct 14, 2011
Tags: cement plant, civil structure, crore, ctpp, cttp, deepak gupta, division bench, environment clearance, environmental clearance, environmental damage, extenuating circumstances, green bench, ministry of environment, ministry of environment and forests, mw plant, plant and machinery, private firm, sanjay, taking into consideration, thermal power plant